15 valid Venn Diagrams of Categorical Syllogisms

Introduction

There are 15 valid Venn diagrams of categorical syllogisms.

The Logic of Venn Diagrams

Universal Affirmative (A)

All S are P.

 

Universal Negative (E)

No S are P.

 

Particular Affirmative (I)

Some S are P.

 

Particular Negative (O)

Some S are not P.

 

Categorical Syllogism

The Rules for Valid Categorical Syllogisms

  • must have only three terms, each of which designates the same class throughout.
  • cannot have two negative premises.
  • must have a negative conclusion if either premise is negative.
  • cannot have a conclusion with a existential quantity if both premises are universal in quantity.
  • must distribute the major term in the major premise if the major term is distributed in the conclusion.
  • must have a distributed minor term in the minor premise if the minor term is distributed in the conclusion.
  • must have a distributed middle term in at least one premise.

 

Figures

 

Valid Argument Forms

Figure 1 AAA, AII, EAE, EIO
Figure 2 AEE, AOO, EAE, EIO
Figure 3 AII, EIO, IAI, OAO
Figure 4 AEE, EIO, IAI

Figure 1

AAA

All M is P.
All S is M.
All S is P.

 

 

AII

All M is P.
Some S is M.
Some S is P.

 

 

EAE

No M is P.
All S is M.
All S is P.

 

 

EIO

No M is P.
Some S is M.
Some S is not P.

 

 

Figure 2

AEE

All P is M.
No S is M.
No S is P.

 

 

AOO

All P is M.
Some S is not M.
Some S is not P.

 

 

EAE

No P is M.
All S is M.
No S is P.

 

 

EIO

No P is M.
Some S is M.
Some S is not P.

 

 

Figure 3

AII

All M is P.
Some M is S.
Some S is P.

 

 

EIO

No M is P.
Some M is S.
Some S is not P.

 

 

IAI

Some M is P.
All M is S.
Some S is P.

 

 

OAO

Some M is not P.
All M is S.
Some S is not P.

 

 

Figure 4

AEE

All P is M.
No M is S.
No S is P.

 

 

EIO

No P is M.
Some M is S.
Some S is not P.

 

 

IAI

Some P is M.
All M is S.
Some S is P.

 

 

답글 남기기

이메일 주소는 공개되지 않습니다. 필수 필드는 *로 표시됩니다